Friday, April 26, 2024

What I Think Nikon Can Do To Make Their Cameras Even Better Than They Are


Now that I’ve primarily shot with the Nikon Z8 for several months, as well as recently with the Zf, and with the ability to directly compare them to my years-long experience with other Nikons, Fujifilm and Olympus/OM cameras, I think there are some changes, improvements and additions Nikon can implement to make their excellent cameras even better.  Or so I think so.

DISCLAIMER:  These are my opinions from my point of view based upon my knowledge, experiences, my use of several camera systems and the types of photography I practice.  You and your needs and wants may be entirely different.  My opinion may not be your opinion and that is perfectly okay.  I’m not in the business of deciding what’s good, bad or best for anyone else.  You won’t see the Internet influencers posting a disclaimer such as this.  Most want you to believe they are the authority on gear, what's good, what's bad and your needs.  

First of all, I think the Nikon Z8 is the most capable digital camera I’ve ever owned when it comes to both the quality of the image files and ‘getting the shot.’  Second only to the Nikon Zf, it has the overall best image quality of any digital camera I’ve owned.  

The Z8 is better than my Fujifilm X-T5 in some ways and better than my OM-1 in some ways.  On the other side of the coin, my Nikons don’t have all of the extensive features of the OM-1, some of which are very nice to have but rarely used, nor the external controls I love of the X-T5, which is still my favorite camera to use on a daily basis.  Still, the Z8 is the most capable camera I own.  I'm not sure what I have just written really explains what I mean but I digress.

That said, here are some things I think Nikon can do to make the Z8 better as well as selected other mirrorless cameras in their current lineup even better.  Here are my thoughts in no particular order.

Nikon Z8
First, add a live clipped highlights and crushed shadows warning feature in the viewfinder as well as on the LCD.  Now, other than the histogram, you have no real warning you are clipping highlights or crushing shadows.  When playing back images you’ve already made, Nikon gives you the ability to see clipped highlights.  But not live.  Some cameras only show clipped highlights with so-called "zebras.”  I think OM has the best solution in that they show clipped highlights in the EVF as orange (some say red but mine are clearly orange) areas and crushed shadows as blue areas.  There is no mistaking them.  They immediately get your attention and you can change exposure rapidly.  In fact, I feel it works so well, I no longer use the histogram (nor display it in the EVF) when using the OM-1.  I'm sure Nikon can implement this, most likely in a firmware update.  Let's do it Nikon!  It really makes a substantial difference when speed is a factor.

Second, allow Pre-Release (Pro Capture or Pre-Capture on other cameras) to record in the lossless compressed raw format instead of only JPEG.  What a shame Nikon only allows JPEGs for the pre-capture feature.  I'm not sure why this is so, but Fujifilm and OM can easily do it with raw files so I suspect Nikon can as well.  Again, let's do it Nikon!

Third, implement dual CFExpress B cards instead of a combination of CFExpress B and SDXC cards in the camera bodies that are large enough to handle the larger size.  This is the way the industry is moving in the same way it was with DSLRs moving to mirrorless.  Nikon was late to the party with mirrorless, let's not be late to the party for most of your cameras for this change as well.  

For general photography I like to use the CFExpress B card as my primary storage and the SDXC card as an automatic backup.  Speed and buffer capacity is not really a worry.  But when photographing birds-in-flight or other subjects that require a very high fps, the SD card slows the read/write process down and, in turn, the camera's ability to continue at high frame rates (Note: I do use the fastest SDXC cards).  

My current methodology using my Z8 for high speed photography with the slower SD cards is to only use the CFExpress B card with those high frame rates.  I don't use the SD card for simultaneous backup.  Then when I have a bit of time, I copy the images to the SD card in-camera.  Now I have my backup files.  Right now, that is the best(?) of both worlds.  But it would be nice to have two high speed cards for those occasions when they are needed.

Fourth, GPS built-in to the Z8 and the future Z6III and potentially Z7III.  In-camera GPS is not an absolute must but it sure is nice when traveling day after day and photographing in many different places.  Also, it works better than having to import GPS data using Nikon's app.  I don't use GPS often, but when I want to use it, it is a pain to figure it out.

Fifth, keep improving the AF subject detection.  It is very good right now but still not quite industry leading.  Very close from everything I read and see.  But it also could be better.  Nikon still uses the icons and terminology for detecting 'cats and dogs.'  Let's change that to animals and teach your AI and machine learning algorithms to recognize all four legged mammals flawlessly.

Sixth, fix how the Shooting Banks/Custom Banks combination work.  Compared to other cameras I've used, the way Nikon has engineered this feature is really not very conducive to efficiency nor nearly as well done as other manufacturers.  In fact, the way Nikon has engineered the C1,C2, etc., User Settings in the Z6-7 series cameras works better than how it is configured in the higher cost cameras.  I don't get it?  Give us one place to save all of our settings, not two that save only some settings.  This is a no-brainer in my opinion.

ADDITION (04/27/2024):  I knew there was one other feature that I would like Nikon to address.  When using focus bracketing, the EVF and LCD on Nikon cameras go completely black for the duration of the several exposures set by the user.  OM cameras allow the user to view the variety of exposures and the changes in focus distance live.  That really helps if you are attempting a handheld focus bracketed photograph.  Having that visual reference as the exposures are taking place, at least for me, helps me steady the camera better so the subsequent exposures can be composited more easily and more accurately.  If OM can provide a live view while focus bracketing, I would think Nikon could as well.  It does increase usability.  Seriously.

Nikon does almost everything right.  But there is always room for improvement and that includes all of us as photographers.  I hope Nikon sees this and will take some of what I write under consideration.

Is there something about the camera or cameras you use that you wish were different?  Leave a comment and let us all know.

Join me over at my website, https://www.dennismook.com
 

Thanks for looking. Enjoy!  

Dennis A. Mook  

All content on this blog is © 2013-2024 Dennis A. Mook. All Rights Reserved. Feel free to point to this blog from your website with full attribution. Permission may be granted for commercial use. Please contact Mr. Mook to discuss permission to reproduce the blog posts and/or images.

4 comments:

  1. Hi Dennis, as someone who hasn't even handled, let alone shot with either a Z8 of Zf, I'm not sure I understood a statement you made, and wondering if you might clarify. From your results, do you think the Zf has the best image quality?

    "Second only to the Nikon Zf, it has the overall best image quality of any digital camera I’ve owned."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I figured I would need to explain so thank you for asking. The Zf has a 24mp full frame sensor with the latest and greatest Nikon 14-bit image processor. That combination produces images that have more dynamic range and less noise than my 45mp Z8 (same image processor), the 40mp Fujifilm X-T5 (the sensor is about 1/2 the size of a full frame sensor) and the 20mp 12-bit OM-1 (it’s sensor is about 1/4th the size of a full frame sensor). For low light and high ISO photography the Zf does better than the other cameras. In bright daylight, you really can’t tell the difference, as I’ve written many times. Additionally, and I’ve mentioned this, it just be my imagination, but the colors I see from the Zf just seem to be more pleasing to me than those from my other cameras. I really like what I see coming straight out of the camera.

      To further explain my above points, as we all know larger individual pixels (24mp on a full frame sensor versus 45mp on a full frame sensor versus 40mp on a APS-C sensor or even 20mp on a micro4/3 sensor) mean lower noise and more dynamic range at higher ISOs due to the ability of those individual pixels to absorb more photons. Even though the Z8 has more resolution as does the X-T5, that additional resolution is inconsequential in the vast majority of my photography. I like having it, it is nice to have when needed, kind of like a spare tire in your trunk (boot), but for most of my work, 24mp is sufficient. Forty-five million pixels is overkill.

      When I say overall image quality, I consider 12-bit versus 14-bit color, digital noise and dynamic range. Sharpness and contrast is mostly a product of lenses. When I consider those three factor, to me, the Zf wins. Don’t get me wrong, my other cameras produce excellent images and I have no complaints, but the Zf holds a slight edge. One last thing. Some of the differences in image quality and pixel count differences can be mitigated by the modern AI based software plug-ins we now have. Higher noise levels and resolution differences can be eliminated using Topaz, DXO, On1 and other programs. Technology, as I’ve written, is the great equalizer.

      I hope this helps. If not, keep asking. ~Dennis

      Delete
  2. The difficulties with hand held focus bracketing is a big one for me. Olympus/OM makes it so easy to extend DOF in macro and telephoto landscape situations with the hand held focus bracketing feature. I use it all the time. I have tried, with little success, to hand hold the Z during focus bracketing. If the Canon R6 can do it, then Nikon can surely implement the feature for hand held use.
    I recently found the Nikon "SUNDAY" color profile. I think the colors just sing in this profile. Don't know how they did it but I am a fan!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am in agreement with you. Thank you for your comment. ~Dennis

      Delete